Looking for design inspiration?   Browse our curated collections!

Return to Main Discussion Page
Discussion Quote Icon

Discussion

Main Menu | Search Discussions

Search Discussions
 
 

Diana Angstadt

8 Years Ago

Critique Please?

Sell Art Online

Reply Order

Post Reply
 

Brittaney Gresham

8 Years Ago

I think apart of the white is to bright. I only mention is because I have that problem sometimes lol. but other than that I like it

 

Angelina Tamez

8 Years Ago

I like the composition, it kind of hurts my eyes to look at it though, it's so bright.

 

Suzanne Powers

8 Years Ago

Great composition and contrast with shadows! I agree with everyone else I would turn down the whites.

 

Gary Fossaceca

8 Years Ago

Really cool shot. I agree on the whites as well.

 

Mike Savad

8 Years Ago

its different, it could be a little less blurry. the legs and shadows at the very top are distracting. i'd rather see the shadows of the 3 in front of me, not in front of them. the angle of the floor bugs me, but mostly that seam in the floor.

---Mike Savad
MikeSavad.com

 

Diana Angstadt

8 Years Ago

I actually turned up the whites in photoshop cause I want to hang it in a room with gray walls. Wanted to white to pop a little. Thanks! May change it back!

 

David Bridburg

8 Years Ago

Diana,

There is the center of the image which might be a focal point, but I see your camera pointing even further down under center.
This sets up a dynamic. I personally much prefer images where the horizon is one focal point and the camera is tilted slightly upward
for the second focal point. The dynamic is much better that way, jmo. If the second main focal point is pointed down, you are looking into
the ground.

Dave

 

Diana Angstadt

8 Years Ago

Thank you all! It is high key, but probably too high key, so thanks for your input.. I purposely made it this way.. not by default. Yes, not in clear sharp focus, but actually, none of it is. so in my opinion that is okay, if it is all soft. Mike.. the legs are what I feel makes this pic! Yeah, just having fun..

 

Robert Kernodle

8 Years Ago

.
I deleted what I first wrote, because I could not execute what I suggested, and so I think that I had misgivings.

The lights seem too blown out to fix in relation to the other tones.

Undo the lightening that you did and show us what THAT looks like.

Black still pops from gray.

 

Roger Swezey

8 Years Ago

I have to disagree about the "blown out white"...I think the image as it is, stands out from the crowd

I agree with Mike about deleting the fourth shadow and whatever that rectangle is in the upper right.

And eliminating the seam line.

But I like the point of view angle...a bit out of the ordinary.

And of course the blurriness of the shadows.

This image certainly has in my opinion, a unique and intriguing presence.

 

Robert Kernodle

8 Years Ago

Deleting the fourth shadow would seem to imply adding even more of the bright to an already very bright image, which would imply deleting the legs casting those shadows, to make the image logical, ... adding yet MORE bright areas.





 

Roger Swezey

8 Years Ago

Exactly

 

This discussion is closed.