20% off all products!   Sale ends tonight at midnight EST.

Return to Main Discussion Page
Discussion Quote Icon

Discussion

Main Menu | Search Discussions

Search Discussions
 

Reply Order

Post Reply
 

Cynthia Decker

8 Years Ago

Art. I like it. It's like playing a visual game of telephone. The message is repeated but some things are left out, simplified, changed, or added. It's a different look at something, and to me it reflects well on the original photographs, which are openly credited and the artist even encourages people to appreciate them.

For example, the photograph of Marion Anderson is absolutely breathtaking - even more so after seeing the oversimplified play doh version.

"For my day job writing press releases, I take projects artists haven't spoken about or they have in complex language and I try to translate those ideas in a palatable kind of way; that’s what I’m attempting to do with the original photographs in Play-Doh … you have to try to be a funnel between the artist and the rest of the world. People spend so much time seeing so many images each day but spend so little time on them. What this project does is grab their attention and hopefully leads them to look at the original image. I’m trying to catch people’s attention to have a look at it in the first place.”

 

Greg Jackson

8 Years Ago

Interesting. Derivative perhaps?

 

Edward Fielding

8 Years Ago

Like a new arrangement of a popular song perhaps?

 

Marlene Burns

8 Years Ago

how about 'art or just a different medium?'

In her own words she is trying to get people to pay attention to photography.....all's well in my book . ;)

 

Kevin Callahan

8 Years Ago

Many years ago when I was the Creative Director for a publishing company I art directed one of our cover shoots each month. One month we used Gingerbread men to represent business men. I cut out Play-doh ties and accessories to give each "man" a different look. It was a very successful cover.

 

Edward Fielding

8 Years Ago

I love the gingerbread men idea!

 
 

Jean Hall

8 Years Ago

These are GREAT! I didn't know quite what to expect, but these are just terrific. If they're "derivative," well -- so was Shakespeare. (The plots to a lot of his plays came from other sources. He just made them wonderful.)

 

Edward Fielding

8 Years Ago

Just as an aside: I've been watching Game of Thrones on DVD and some history channel series on the Roman empire --- it hit me how similar a lot of the themes were. And then I turn on the TV and see how the Iraq army sucks because the leaders that were trained by the U.S. were replaced by political appointees. Just like how the early Roman leader were which lead to the barbarians kicking their butt.

Visual influences are easier to see but certainly every creative field "borrows" -- sometimes too much.

 

Edward Fielding

8 Years Ago

Here are some more. Also consider the some of these might fall under parody laws.

https://www.behance.net/gallery/4204047/Visual-essay-about-plagiarism


Copyright, plagiarism, parody - oh my!

 

Suzanne Powers

8 Years Ago

Cool art using Play-doh! I think we have to be careful with that word "plagiarism." I only had time to see the simple Play-doh images, they are too different from the original photos to be taken seriously as plagiarism.

 

Edward Fielding

8 Years Ago

I think the term visual plagiarism is better than "stealing". Of course its a case by case bases.

There are all kinds of terms - homage, "after", influenced, Art Paraphrasing, reference, tracing, copying or alluding, fan art

This is a rather good journal on the subject - http://sacredflamingheart.deviantart.com/journal/What-Is-Art-Plagiarism-READ-THIS-234951828

 

Valerie Reeves

8 Years Ago

Plagiarism? No way. And they are fantastic.

 

Rick Mosher

8 Years Ago

This makes me think of Austin Kleon's book "Steal Like an Artist" This is a link to his TED talk. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oww7oB9rjgw

 

This discussion is closed.