Looking for design inspiration?   Browse our curated collections!

Return to Main Discussion Page
Discussion Quote Icon

Discussion

Main Menu | Search Discussions

Search Discussions
 
 

Robert Kernodle

9 Years Ago

Leaked Secret Government Documents And Copyright

I will introduce this topic by way of a picture. Click on it, and read the DESCRIPTION for background info.

Robert Kernodle Art Prints

The whole leak situation poses an interesting legal conundrum.

Complicate it with a hoax, and it becomes even more interesting.

Reply Order

Post Reply
 

Mary Ellen Anderson

9 Years Ago

???
-- mary ellen anderson

 

Mike Savad

9 Years Ago

i concur with mary.

???


---Mike Savad
MikeSavad.com

 

JC Findley

9 Years Ago

Why are aliens writing in Hebrew

 

TL Mair

9 Years Ago

That's where the lost tribes went J.C..
Terry
tlmair

 

Elizabeth Bathory

9 Years Ago

You guys are hilarious. Terry ..that is so funny...lol...should come here more often on the weekend....lol

 

Mike Savad

9 Years Ago

actually some of that is japanese. actually i think all of it is, but using a klingon kind of script.


---Mike Savad
MikeSavad.com

 

Jane McIlroy

9 Years Ago

To answer the original question, the copyright probably belongs to the alien who invented it (whatever it is).

 

Robert Kernodle

9 Years Ago

Okay, let me spell it out:

Documents, pictures, graphic artwork produced by government employees, paid by taxpayer dollars ... are in the public domain, and these works have NO copyright protection, by definition.

Now some guy with the pseudo name, Isaac, comes along and claims to reveal secret Defense Department drawings of alien technology. IF we are to believe the story of the person who uploaded the original images, then these images are now in the public domain, with NO copyright protection. The only way that the person, thus, could claim copyright on those images would be to deny his whole story about the images being produced by government employees. He, then, could claim the images, ONLY by admitting that his whole story was a hoax.

This person who uploaded those images has NOT denied his story, and so the images are free for anybody to use, as I see it.

I used them.

This issue is interesting, and it raises a question:

Are leaked secret government documents automatically in the public domain and immediately unprotected by copyrights?

My answer is "yes".

Practically speaking the only answer is "yes".

Legally, however, the answer might not be so straightforward.

Any thoughts?

To clarify:

The elaborate story was that government employees, NOT aliens, produced the graphics, which depict alien technology that the Defense Department was trying to duplicate and apply for Earthly use. The symbols are NOT definitively Japanese. They are a fantasy alphabet created by the perpetrator of this bizarre tale. But in holding to this tale, the individual gives away his artwork - he has no claim on it, other than he stole it and made it public.

I took the original graphics and digitally transformed, enhanced, layered and composed them into the image that I posted at the beginning of this thread.




 

Maybe Mr Snowden or Assange can answer.

But I do think you raise interesting points and the resultant artwork is pretty cool.

 

This discussion is closed.