Return to Main Discussion Page

Discussion

Main Menu | Search Discussions

Search Discussions

 
 

Dan Carmichael

1 Year Ago

Why You Can't Do What You Want On Fine Art America

There have been lively debates lately about rules, policies, etc. on Fine Art America.

Reading it all, I have been surprised that the focus of debate is about the specific rule or policy, and that a much larger point is being overlooked. And that larger point goes well beyond any single policy.

http://fineartamerica.com/blogs/why-you-cant-do-what-you-want-on-fine-art-america.html

Reply Order

Post Reply
 

Tom Druin

1 Year Ago

glad you did not use images to get your point across ....

 

Dan Carmichael

1 Year Ago

Hmmm. Interesting comment. Never thought of it. But yea, now that I understand your reference, I agree!

 

Conor OBrien

1 Year Ago

Nice analogy!

 

Ann Powell

1 Year Ago

There are lots of private companies that do change their rules and policies due to "pressure" put on them by their customers to make a change. So, while I agree it is immature to have a tantrum about it, I can see why people do express their disagreements, and/or request for changes to policies. I do believe that there have been changes made based on reasonable input from customers here.

 

Christine Till

1 Year Ago


Oh Dan ..... you're so desperate, and sometimes you're trying too hard ... you certainly don't miss a single chance to get your name out, no matter what !!

 

Dan Carmichael

1 Year Ago

@ Christine:
"Oh Dan ..... you're so desperate ... you certainly don't miss a single chance to get your name out, no matter what !!"

Christine,

I hope you were joking about that. If not, it's somewhat, well..."trollish"

There was no attempt to "get my name out."

I am here to sell art. If I was going to do anything at all in the "promotional" arena, it would certainly be associated with my work, and images would be included. And it certainly would not be buried in an in-house blog on FAA.

 

Dan Turner

1 Year Ago

I'm pretty sure she meant to say "Mike Savad" but fell into the wrong thread.

Dan Turner
Dan Turner Fine Art
Dan Turner's Seven Keys to Selling Art Online
To Enjoy Dan Turner's Pinterest Boards, Click Here

 

Dan Carmichael

1 Year Ago

@Dan

LOL. Funny, but the same thought ran across my mind (and yes, I like mike).

But let's add to it JC.

You know, all those "desperate" people in the forums making too many posts.

You know, all those "desperate" people that basically sell every day.

 

Christine Till

1 Year Ago


Hahahaha ... to both of you :-)
You definitely know me too well, especially you, Dan ;-)

Anyway, I truly believe you're too good for this kind of threads and blog posts, Dan.

 

Dan Carmichael

1 Year Ago


Christine,

Well, a little confused here. Don't know what you mean by that. I'm just a person who has always had the burden of speaking my opinion.

 

Dan Carmichael

1 Year Ago

Besides, I can't post threads that contain images to promote myself because I'll get jumped on by Dan! LOL! (wink, wink dan)

 

Christine Till

1 Year Ago


So did and do I, Dan.

 

Dan Carmichael

1 Year Ago


Besides, I have grown tired of jousting at windmills. FAA has its problems, but it is a good place, I sell here, and it is comprised of some really great people.

 

Dan Turner

1 Year Ago

"Besides, I can't post threads that contain images to promote myself because I'll get jumped on by Dan!"

I like the discussions. Look at the ground we've covered just today: masturbating women, advertising your work, rock 'n roll, photojournalism, license negotiations, suing the pants off people vs the golden rule, Adobe subscriptions. I get none of that in the image threads. Nada.

Dan Turner
Dan Turner Fine Art
Dan Turner's Seven Keys to Selling Art Online
To Enjoy Dan Turner's Pinterest Boards, Click Here

 

Christine Till

1 Year Ago


Of course it's a good place, Dan, and of course it's comprised of some really GREAT people.
Otherwise I would not be here.

But there is a fine line between great people and simple (and sometimes sick) exhibitionism, but obviously only I can see it. So just disregard my post.

 

Dan Carmichael

1 Year Ago

@Christine
"but obviously only I can see it"

Sounds like the old "the whole world is wrong, but I'm right" philosophy.

Perhaps that's not the case. Perhaps the world is right and it is your perceptions that are flawed, skewed, and biased.

 

Deborah Verhoeven

1 Year Ago

Your blog posting makes sense to me.

 

Jenny Armitage

1 Year Ago

Actually, one of the biggest differences between FAA and much other private business web-space, is that even if you can't do whatever you want, you do get to, " flail your arms and legs about and throw a hissy fit," on the forum almost indefinitely. On most sales sites anything like a complaint is shut down pretty early on the forums. I think Sean must subscribe to the Dr. Spock method of child/artist raising. ;)

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

I'm laughing hysterically right now. Thank you, Dan. This was long overdue.

 

Roy Erickson

1 Year Ago

If you don't like the rules here - as I said to 19 year old boy child - the door is there - go make a place for yourself - and he did. Poor child has had his ups and downs with life - but which of us has not. I'm sure that there are printers that are only too willing to take on a new venue and make some more money off of your ruleless POD site.

and to each of us - the whole world IS wrong and we are right. but most often - we have to just grin and bare it.

 

Tony Reddington

1 Year Ago

doctor spock? thought he was an alien

 

Drew

1 Year Ago

"Why You Can't Do What You Want On Fine Art America"
Now Dan, that depends on what you want to do does it not? many of FAA members do exactly what they want to do on FAA.
BTW, your blog is right on target:)

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

Hello Dan, I call it expressing yourself, freedom of speech as long as the comments remain in context. I joined in October I think and there were a few discussion threads and some of my comments where zapped! I can not help but laugh because I remember saying once the discussion threads some of them reminded me of the old aol chat forums.....

 

JC Findley

1 Year Ago

Oh, cool, an image sharing thread...

This is my latest, please buy it now.

Art Prints

This is specifically for the censors, as she is nude and I will be adding porn to the keywords, and for Roger, because he will see I have not yet acknowledged the sculptor but I am trying to figure out who did it and where it is from....

Did I mention I will give a 1% discount?

 

Christine Till

1 Year Ago


LOL, JC. Good one!

Big Skip

This is a very popular discussion with 78 responses.   In order to help the page load faster and allow you to quickly read the most recent posts, we're only showing you the oldest 25 posts and the newest 25 posts.   Everything in the middle has been skipped.   Want to read the entire discussion?   No problem: click here.

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

I was once told on another photo site a woman described my photo with the spanish word for Veg. as posted by Abbie. As an example I have posted my photo of forks here in this forum..., in the instance on the other site because of what the other artist commented about my submission generated so much attention from her comment, the photo attained the recognition it deserved. My comment was it was a form of advertising and advertising is a form of commercial art or a photo, it generates business, without it where would the economy be globally....I have not heard that expression in many years we would say here in New Orleans All meat and no potatoes......lol

here is the photo in question......


Sell Art Online

 

Janine Riley

1 Year Ago

This has been most entertaining.

I will never look at a Lunch Menu quite the same again. "Meats & 2 veggies". Lol.

Ya'll are the best. Great Blog Dan.

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

Hello Janine, great comment, I have a beautiful set of silver forks, with mother of peal handles.....lol

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

@ Mike did the matter of your being banned from google ever get lifted because of your method of approach selling your work....I have not noticed any comment back from you about that.....your personal situation is a good example.....

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

@Dan, personally I think all your discussion threads have certainly brought anot of interest to you personally, a potential client may see them and may generate more business than you can imagine.....

 

Mike Savad

1 Year Ago

banned forever from google plus, but seeing as i didn't stop getting sales, anything that i got must have been a coincidence. they gave me a vague list of rules of what it might have been so who knows what it was. i remember getting into an argument with one person there, banned her, and for all i know she complained and it went down then. no idea, and no way to correct my actions. oh well.


---Mike Savad

 

Dan Carmichael

1 Year Ago

@Michael
"@Dan, personally I think all your discussion threads have certainly brought anot of interest to you personally, a potential client may see them and may generate more business than you can imagine....."

LOL. You've got a great sense of humor, Michael! LOL!

Seriously... I do not do it for sales. Yes, there may be some help here on FAA, but I remain convinced that potential buyers do not spend time looking at groups, reading forum posts, etc. People don't have time. If somebody wants an image for their new beach house, they jump on an art site, enter "lighthouse" into the search, do the transaction, and get on with their life.

I honestly believe that more can be accomplished if time and effort is spent in promotions outside of FAA. Any time spent here is probably better spent elsewhere.

That is why I asked about the benefits of forum posting in a thread created days before this one. I am not convinced many buyers have the desire, nor the time, to read these forums. If they are interested in any particular artist(s), they would be more likely to read the artist's blog to learn more about them, than they would be searching thru a forum looking for random posts here and there.

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

@Mike that always is in the back of my mind, someone with your high standards and reputation as a superior artist because of a rule that just seems unjust and seems somehow can be reversed...FAA promotes me on Facebook, and I download my work for everyone to see there.....and other have promoted me on google, but I fear of self promoting my work there because of your experience with them.....its baffling.....you would think they would have something like amnesty.....

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

@Dan that is exactly correct it all boils down to the potential client typing in a keyword and moving on with there life......

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

@Dan that is exactly correct it all boils down to the potential client typing in a keyword and moving on with there life......

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

@Dan that is exactly correct it all boils down to the potential client typing in a keyword and moving on with there life......

 

R Allen Swezey

1 Year Ago

JC,

Adolph Alexander Weinman (American, 18701952). Night, Clock Figure from Pennsylvania Station, 31st to 33rd Streets between 7th and 8th Avenues, NYC, circa 1910. Pink granite, with base: 152 x 86 x 52 in. (386.1 x 218.4 x 132.1 cm). Brooklyn Museum, Gift of Lipsett Demolition Co. and Youngstown Cartage, 66.250.1

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

Allen the Britts can not take claim for that wording, but people in Mississippi USA used that expression many many many years ago, and it was punn used by happy people men or women, all meat and no potatoes, or all potatoes and no meat...lol it was a polite thing to say when in public......where exactly that expression originated who knows but its been used commonly among gay and straight friends I know........instead of being obscene or valgar in public....

 

JC Findley

1 Year Ago

You rock Roger, thanks....

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

Oh BTW I only remember seeing one post, so does this mean someone in the discussion duplicated my post.....hummmm


oh I forgot its one of those bugs, I call them glitch....lol

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

ROFLMAO! Thanks again, Michael. England was established long before the US. No matter how long ago Mississippi used it, England was using it before it was even thought of as a state.

 

Marcio Faustino

1 Year Ago

So it means we can't access FAA when we are making a crap? lol

 

Cynthia Decker

1 Year Ago

'Meat and two veg' has replaced 'twig and berries' as my favorite euphemism!

I'm relatively new to the forums, but I don't see an issue with someone promoting themselves and trying to stay relevant and visible on a site that is designed to help artists promote themselves, stay relevant and visible. Just an observation. *shrug*

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

@Marcio, if you have a PC you are in tough luck, lol

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

Ok I agree, you are 150 percent correct on that one...lol

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

@Dan has posted a discussion page to show your veggies, lol

 

Michael Hoard

1 Year Ago

@Dan has posted a discussion page to show your veggies, lol

All I have to post is a potato from Mississippi which does look like Richard Nixon....lol

this is a untouched photo its a potato with eyes, a nose, mouth, and a pimple or blimish.....

Sell Art Online

 

May we keep this to a slightly sensible thread. It actually has some good points I do not want lost in jokes.

 

John Lyes

1 Year Ago

All rules are meant to be broken

 

Jenny Armitage

1 Year Ago

John,

Go start your own website or blog or something. Anything.

I'm not offended by nudity, or sex, or masturbation. I've been known to engage in all three. But I'm here to sell and my paintings don't go with pornography. That's a different audience. And this site is not it.

Shock art is usually more shock than art. Anyone can make a picture of shiting on the Bible, the Koran, on the a statue of Buddha. I could take a photo of my husband's penis, but it wouldn't be art, just a snap shot. It takes no skill to shock and one depiction is no more shocking than another and rarely more artful. Anyone can do a crotch shot with or without a stimulating hand. If one isn't any better than another, it ain't art. Mapplethorpe, was a brilliant photographer, whether shooting flowers or kinky gay sex. But there was a hell of a lot more there than shock to his images. They were brilliantly composed and beautiful There was skill involved beyond the shock. But it still wouldn't belong here outside the anti porn screen. People have a right to choose what they want to see. They may well want to see Mapplethorpe, but they don't deserve to have Mapplethorpe thrust upon them.

Take it where people expect to see it. Grow up.

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

John - If all rules are meant to be broken please go to the nearest movie theatre, buy a ticket and go into the movie. Wait about a half hour after the movie has started and either yell "fire" or "gun." Let me know how breaking that rule works out for you.

 

Jeff Kolker

1 Year Ago

Or go to an IRS audit and tell them that "all rules are meant to be broken".

There are appropriate places for most things, but not every place is appropriate.

 

This discussion is closed.