Return to Main Discussion Page

Discussion

Main Menu | Search Discussions

Search Discussions

 
 

Kalevi Tamm

1 Year Ago

Combination Of Multiple Photos - Is It Allowed?

Hi, as I'm new here, I have question. I know upsizing is not allowed, which is understandably good, but what about combination of multiple photos, like this "Panoramic stripe" of Cuban doors http://fineartamerica.com/featured/caribbean-colors-kalevi-tamm.html - is it allowed, is it this kind of unusual dimensions suitable for FAA system?
It seems not fit for cards option.

Thanks,

Kalevi

Reply Order

Post Reply
 

Mary Bedy

1 Year Ago

Kalevi, I think other would have a better answer for you, but on a greeting card, I believe the person buying the card can move the image around or at least re-size it. Obviously that panoramic image will not fit correctly on a greeting card, but it's a wonderful image for a print. Very unique.

 

JC Findley

1 Year Ago

Yupp, allowed AND encouraged as it is unique....

I am actually working on an image like this as I type this. (Different subject, same concept.)

 

Charles Kozierok

1 Year Ago

It's certainly allowed, but I would imagine not a lot of customers would have a place to put it.

I do a fair bit of panos myself, but I try to keep the aspect ratio under control as much as possible. :)

 

Mike Savad

1 Year Ago

pano's are fine, but they will appear as a thin strip on the screen and details in the loupe won't be there. because of that they don't often sell. but you can do them. in fact there are 3 reserved sizes and pricing for them.


---Mike Savad

 

Gregory Scott

1 Year Ago

I have lots of panos, and have never sold one.
I'll say that FAA display formats do not work well with extremely wide aspect ratios. I would suggest nothing higher than about 4:1.
I have some that are more like 15:1. very few views for them, much less sales.

Stitching together images generally retains the sharpness and detail of the image, so there is other problem, other than the 25mb size limit, perhaps. You may have to compress a jpg somewhat if it exceeds that limit.

You might want to consider offering this as a diptych or triptych.

 

Harry Lamb

1 Year Ago

I have'nt sold any Panoramics either. Gregory is right; I tend to kep panos between 3:1 and 4:1. I don't see anything stopping you though.

 

Angelina Vick

1 Year Ago

Yes...they are allowed. =)

Because printing is done off of whatever size your image is...it doesn't have to be a standard size.

 

Kalevi Tamm

1 Year Ago

Thanks to everyone for helpful suggestions!

Kalevi

 

Ryan Burton

1 Year Ago

Decided to try a panoramic. Hoping this might ketch someone’s eye. And this is my first try at a panoramic so I would love some feedback.
Art Prints

 

Yury Yanin

1 Year Ago

...I know upsizing is not allowed...
Upsizing is not prohibited, it is not recommended. When you upsize an image in Photoshop, the resulting image usually becomes blurry or blocky, which is bad for printing. FAA tries to produce prints of a high quality and may regect an order if the downloaded image can not provide a good print of the ordered print size. FAA can not check quality of each uploaded image though, so promotion of your art, providing its printable quality and so on - it is mostly YOUR responsibility. If you can provide a printable quality of parts and the whole picture and hope to sell such panoramic pictures - you are on your own.

 

Lynn Palmer

1 Year Ago

@Mike I've been creating panos and dyptychs, what are the reserve sizes and prices.

 

Paul Cowan

1 Year Ago

The loupe does give full size views on panos.

 

Patrick Jacquet

1 Year Ago

Another alternative beside panoramics is to upload a "standard" landscape version (when possible of course !)

Sell Art Online

Art Prints

 

Mark Papke

1 Year Ago

I have upsized a couple images just out of curiosity to see how much it degrades, not for FAA just for my self. I went from a 16mp taken with my D7000 to 24mp and there really isn't any degradation that I can tell. I also just got a D600 and upsized a picture from 24mp up to 32mp first and then to 48mp and both looked great. I saw an article online talking about whether you need D800 when you have a D600 because upsizing images works so well on a D600, so I tried it out. Sometime I'll try to push it farther. I guess it all depends on the camera, lens, and how much upsizing you do. I wouldn't try it probably on an entry level camera and cheap lens.

 

Gregory Scott

1 Year Ago

I want to correct Paul's statement: "The loupe does give full size views on panos."

This is not always true, particularly on very large, very high aspect ratio images.
Here is a thread where I documented the issue:

http://fineartamerica.com/showmessages.php?messageid=1085023

 

This discussion is closed.